UN opens a path toward autonomous weapons rules by 2028 ... but there are problems
After 14 years of talks, 128 countries agreed Friday to something: 2 more years of talks.
The Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons concluded in Geneva with an agreement to launch a formal process toward an international instrument governing lethal autonomous weapons systems, with 2028 as the target. What kind of instrument, and whether it binds anyone who develops or deploys autonomous weapons, was left for the next round to decide.
One unnamed diplomat summarized it as "disappointing but could have been much worse."
The reality, of course, is that we're already seeing autonomous weapons being deployed in the Russia-Ukraine war.
What the agreement actually says
Conference president Julien Thoeni announced that the 128 state parties "agreed to launch the elaboration of an international instrument on lethal autonomous weapons systems, which should be conducted over the next two years." The key word is "instrument." That covers everything from a binding treaty to a voluntary set of principles with no enforcement mechanism.
The CCW requires consensus among all 128 state parties, meaning any single country can block an agreement.
Russia raised procedural objections throughout the week, forcing cancellation of some formal meetings and pushing final text negotiations to 4:45 AM Saturday. The United States and Israel also opposed binding protocols.
The Humanoid Technology Expo is where the builders, integrators, and enterprise buyers shaping this space come together. Early registration is open.
A problem that is not waiting
Autonomous and AI-guided weapons are not a future concern.
They are active in Ukraine, Sudan, and the Middle East right now, with some systems using AI to identify targets and, in some configurations, removing the human from the trigger decision entirely. The existing laws of armed conflict were written for weapons that a person aims and fires, and they do not map cleanly onto systems that make those determinations themselves.
The International Committee of the Red Cross has said existing humanitarian law does not adequately address the specific risks from autonomous weapons, including unpredictable behavior and fatal errors. The ICRC has pushed for a ban on weapons that select and attack targets without meaningful human control.
Who wanted more and who did not
Around 100 countries supported legally binding rules on a faster timeline. Austria, Belgium, Brazil, Ireland, Mexico, New Zealand, and Panama jointly proposed binding negotiations outright. UN Secretary-General António Guterres had pushed for a binding deal by 2026. His target slipped by 2 years, and even 2028 is not a binding deadline.
"Technology is moving faster than diplomacy," says Ambassador Frederico Meyer of Brazil. "Diplomats are very slow."
"Delaying the creation of a legally binding instrument puts civilians and humanity at risk," says Nicole van Rooijen, executive director of Stop Killer Robots.
Thoeni called the outcome "a significant achievement for humanitarian disarmament after more than 10 years of talks." Others suggested that is remains possible and probably even likely that there will be no treaty by the end of 2028.
Fourteen years
The CCW has been discussing lethal autonomous weapons since 2013.
As of now, however, the defense contractors developing and deploying autonomous systems face no near-term restrictions.
And the ICRC’s stated position says that the laws of war built for human soldiers are being applied to systems that operate outside the assumptions those laws were written around.
What to watch
The 2-year process that begins now needs the same consensus to conclude.
The major autonomous weapons powers, the United States, Russia, and Israel, have not indicated any interest in constraining their own programs. China, also a significant developer of autonomous military systems, has been ambiguous. Getting to something legally binding by 2028 requires all of them to agree, and none of them agreed to binding on Friday.
Sources
In this story
Follow to get an alert when they're in the news
Humanoid (almost) Daily
The humanoid robot news that matters, with context from HumanoidMegaHub's tracking. Free, almost every day.
Keep reading
Written by
I tell stories with data and build startups. I've raised angel and VC funds, led software companies and startups, and chronicled the rise of the mobile economy. Currently I write for Forbes, host several podcasts, and am starting up HumanoidMegaHub. I was TUNE's mobile economist and Singular's VP of Insights, built the research team at VentureBeat, and managed teams creating software for partners like Intel and Disney. In past lives I built websites, e-learning platforms, and mobile apps, and, a long time ago, was named to Folio's top 100 of the media industry's "most innovative entrepreneurs and market shaker-uppers.”